Shoulder Dislocation First Time Or Recurrent (Bankart)
Written by: Dr. Popovitz.
Board-Certified Orthopedic Surgeon | Fellowship-Trained Sports Medicine, NYU Langone Medical Center | FAAOS
Co-Founder, NY Bone & Joint Specialists | Lenox Hill Hospital - Northwell Health
Recognized: New York Magazine Best Doctor | New York Times Super Doctor | IAOS Leading Physician of the World | IAOS Top Orthopedic Surgeon in New York
Date Published: October 4, 2018
Last Updated: September 22, 2025
Last Medically Reviewed: September 22, 2025
This page has been written and reviewed by a fellowship-trained, board-certified orthopedic surgeon with over 20 years of clinical experience. All clinical claims are supported by peer-reviewed literature and current AAOS and AOSSM guidelines. See References section below.
Book a consultation
Prompt Appointments Available
Upper East Side: 1198 Third Ave | Midtown: 425 Madison Ave
Surgery performed at Lenox Hill Hospital - Northwell Health
DISLOCATED SHOULDER SYMPTOMS
How to tell if your shoulder is dislocated?
A shoulder is dislocated when the ball of the shoulder joint is forced out of the socket, generally after a traumatic injury. It results in heavy pain, makes the shoulder look misshapen, and greatly restricts your range of motion. If you’re experiencing these symptoms, you likely need immediate medical attention to have the joint reset in its proper position.
Shoulder dislocations can be partial or complete, and they vary in the degree of the dislocations and even the direction in which the ball of the joint slips out. Treatment usually depends on the both of these factors.
TYPES OF SHOULDER DISLOCATION
Traumatic Shoulder Dislocation / Bankart
The most common symptoms of a traumatic dislocated shoulder include a complete inability to move the arm and severe pain or numbness from the shoulder to the forearm. The shoulder loses its rounding when completely dislocated, generally causing it to protrude frontward in as an anterior dislocation or, less frequently, backward as a posterior dislocation. An anterior dislocation can result in a Bankart lesion, a tear in the cartilage and ligaments which can destabilize the shoulder and lead to recurrent dislocations; similarly, a posterior dislocation can result in a reverse Bankart lesion.
Partially Dislocated Shoulder/ Subluxating Shoulder
Also known as a subluxed shoulder, a partially dislocated shoulder will cause intense pain and clicking in it. While a subluxing shoulder will usually slip back in to place, it will still result in severe pain and a feeling of instability in the affected shoulder.
Multi-Directional Shoulder Dislocation
On occasion, a shoulder might dislocate in several directions simultaneously. These multi-directional dislocations are the rarest, but they’re not uncommon in patients with hyperflexible joints or connective tissue disorders.
WHAT TO DO FOR A DISLOCATED SHOULDER?
If you have severe pain in your shoudler and notice a deformation of its usual shape, you should visit the nearest emergency room as soon as possible and have the shoulder reset. The emergency room doctors will recommend you follow up with an orthopedic specialist, who will treat the symptoms of the dislocation. After a short physical examination, your orthopedic specialist will take X-rays and an MRI of the affected shoulder to assess any damage to the bone, cartilage, or ligaments. If you’re diagnosed with a tear of the stabilizing cartilage and ligaments, your orthopedic specialist will likely recommend a minimally invasive arthroscopic surgery. But if the shoulder hasn’t suffered significant structural damage, immobilization of the affected shoulder and physical therapy might be the best conservative alternative.
If you are in pain from a dislocated shoulder, there are many treatment options available that can get you back on track in no time. Find out more here or book an appointment with one of our orthopedic specialists here.
_________________________________
EXPERIENCING PAIN? DO YOU HAVE AN INJURY?
Our Specialists are here to help.
Book an appointment with NYC’s best orthopedic specialists to discuss your condition. Fill out the form below and you will receive a call from our office within 5-10 minutes. We’ll book an appointment at a time and location that work for you, and send you a reminder by email.
Bankart Shoulder Dislocation: FAQs
What is a Bankart lesion, and how does it happen?
A Bankart lesion is a tear of the cartilage (labrum) and ligaments on the front edge of the shoulder socket (glenoid), which often occurs when the shoulder dislocates anteriorly (forward). This tear destabilizes the shoulder joint, making recurrent dislocations more likely.
Can a first-time shoulder dislocation heal without surgery?
Yes. Many first dislocations are managed non-surgically with reduction (putting the shoulder back in place), followed by immobilization and a structured physical therapy program. Whether surgery is needed depends on factors like the patient’s age, activity level (especially athletes), evidence of a Bankart or bony Bankart lesion, and risk of recurrence.
What increases the risk of shoulder dislocation recurring?
Recurrence risk is higher in younger patients (especially under ~20), athletes involved in contact or overhead sports, when there is bone loss of the glenoid or humeral head (bony Bankart, Hill-Sachs lesions), or when the labral tear is large or untreated. Also, generalized ligamentous laxity or poor compliance with rehab can contribute.
What are the treatment options for recurrent dislocations or Bankart lesions?
Treatment for recurrent instability often includes arthroscopic Bankart repair to reattach the torn labrum to the glenoid, sometimes combined with procedures to address bone loss (e.g. Latarjet procedure) if needed. Conservative therapy (physical therapy focusing on strength, stability, and motion control) may suffice in less severe cases.
Doctors Seeing Patients for Shoulder Conditions:
Medically Reviewed by Dr. Popovitz.
You can book your appointment with New York Bone & Joint online by submitting the appointment request form here:
Book an appointmentOur Locations
-
Upper East Side: Full Service Orthopedic Center & Walk-In
1198 3rd Avenue, Between 69th and 70th Street New York, NY 10021Physician appointments: Mon–Fri 9am–5:30pm, Sat 8:30am–4:30pm
Physical therapy: Mon–Fri 7am–7pm, Sat 8am–2pmPhone: (212) 759-4553 -
Orthopedic Doctor Midtown Manhattan NYC — New York Bone & Joint Specialists
425 Madison Ave, Suite 200 (second floor) New York, NY 10017 (corner of East 49th Street)Physician appointments: Mon–Fri 8:00 am–6:00 pm
Physical therapy: Mon–Fri 7 am–7 pm, Sat 8 am–2 pmPhone: (212) 759-4553 -
Orthopedic Doctor Upper East Side NYC — New York Bone & Joint Specialists
130 E 67th St New York, NY 10065Physician appointments: Mon–Fri 8:00am–6pm, Sat 8:30am–4:30pm
Physical therapy: Mon–Fri 7am–7pm, Sat 8am–2pmPhone: (212) 759-4553